Blog
View all blogs

CMS CRUSH Proposed Rule Would Expand Medicare and Medicaid Program Integrity Oversight: What Healthcare Organizations Need to Know

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) on November 16, 2026, proposed a broad set of program integrity changes that would significantly expand federal oversight across Medicare, Medicaid, the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP), and the Health Insurance Marketplace. The proposal is a significant step in the administration’s broader focus on program integrity, particularly in healthcare, where federal officials are emphasizing earlier detection of fraud, waste, and abuse and stronger safeguards before payments are made. 

Health Management Associates (HMA) interdisciplinary teams of experts are reviewing the proposed policies and have identified the key issues and considerations addressed in this article. Stakeholders should consider how the proposed changes  could affect provider enrollment, ownership information, documentation, billing oversight, and timely identification of overpayments, all of which have implications for operational and financial risk management. 

CMS CRUSH Proposed Rule Signals a Broader Program Integrity Strategy 

The Comprehensive Regulations to Uncover Suspicious Healthcare (CRUSH) proposed rule (CMS-6098-P) would tighten provider enrollment requirements, improve payment and fraud oversight, create new Medicaid overpayment obligations, and give federal and state agencies additional tools to identify and act against providers and suppliers considered higher risk. Unlike CMS’s annual rulemaking processes for the Medicare and ACA Marketplace programs, CRUSH is a stand-alone program integrity regulation, spanning multiple public programs. CMS has indicated that it intends to engage in this type of program integrity rulemaking annually. 

The breadth of the proposal reflects a larger shift at CMS. The agency is seeking to identify potential issues earlier through better enrollment screening, expanded data collection and information sharing, greater use of prepayment oversight, and more closely coordinated federal and state enforcement activities. 

CMS estimates that the quantified provisions in the proposed rule would produce nearly $90 billion in federal savings between 2027 and 2036, although a substantial share of that estimate is tied to proposed Medicare Advantage Risk Adjustment Data Validation (RADV). These projected federal savings largely reflect changes in payments rather than necessarily reductions in underlying healthcare costs. 

CMS will accept comments on the proposed rule for 60 days following publication in the Federal Register. Organizations that may be affected by these proposals should use the comment period to provide data, operational examples, and policy recommendations that will inform the final rule and shape CMS’s ongoing program integrity initiatives. 

Changes that Matter to Healthcare Providers and Plans 

1. Medicare Provider Enrollment Requirements Would Become More Stringent 

CMS proposes to require all Medicare providers and suppliers to report changes in enrollment information within 30 calendar days. Currently, providers and suppliers have up to 90 days for certain changes. More significant modifications, including new ownership, practice location, and adverse legal actions, already have shorter reporting periods. 

The rule also would give CMS a new basis for denying or revoking Medicare enrollment when it cannot confirm the identity of certain owners, managers, partners, officers, or directors, including foreign or domestic executive personnel, or when CMS determines that an individual or organization presents an undue risk of fraud, waste, or abuse. In addition, the proposal would expand CMS’s discretion to deny or revoke enrollment in connection with certain ownership transactions, potentially introducing additional regulatory considerations for mergers, acquisitions, and other organizational changes. 

HMA Analysis: These proposals increase the necessity of accurate and current enrollment and ownership documentation. Healthcare systems with complex organizational structures, transactions, management changes, or multiple enrollment records may need to consider whether their compliance processes can consistently identify and report changes within the proposed timeframe. 

2. Medicare Advantage Provider Screening Would Move Closer to Original Medicare 

Another consequential change would affect providers that participate in Medicare Advantage (MA). CMS generally does not require a provider that bills an MA plan to maintain approved enrollment in Original Medicare. Instead, CMS uses tools such as its preclusion list to restrict certain providers from receiving MA reimbursement. 

Under the proposed rule, eligible providers and suppliers furnishing services to MA enrollees, including both in-network and out-of-network providers, generally would be required to enroll in Original Medicare using an approved status, with an exception for providers that participate in Program of All-Inclusive Care for the Elderly (PACE) plans. CMS says this approach would allow the agency to apply Medicare enrollment screening requirements, including identity verification, licensure review, site visits, and fingerprint-based background checks, before they furnish MA services. 

The proposal also has implications for MA organizations. CMS would require plans and Part D sponsors to report referrals involving substantiated or suspicious fraud, waste, and abuse and would extend requirements to report payment suspensions associated with credible allegations of fraud to not only pharmacies, but also other types of providers and suppliers. 

HMA Analysis: If finalized as proposed, the requirement would take effect on the first day of the plan year beginning two years after publication of the final rule. Providers and plans may want to consider whether this timeframe will allow them to identify affected network participants and resolve enrollment gaps.

3. Medicare Advantage Risk Adjustment Oversight Would Intensify 

The proposed rule also would strengthen CMS oversight of Medicare Advantage risk adjustment through changes to the Risk Adjustment Data Validation (RADV) program. These changes could have significant financial implications for MA organizations by expanding CMS’s ability to identify and recover payments associated with unsupported diagnoses. 

HMA Analysis: Increased RADV scrutiny reinforces the importance of accurate clinical documentation, diagnosis coding, and internal validation processes. MA organizations should assess their risk adjustment compliance and audit readiness, while providers participating in MA networks should consider whether existing documentation and coding practices adequately support reported diagnoses. 

4. Medicaid Providers Would Face a 60-Day Overpayment Requirement 

One of the most important operational proposals would establish a regulatory framework for reporting and returning self-identified Medicaid fee-for-service (FFS) overpayments within 60 calendar days. Similar requirements already apply in Medicare FFS, Medicare Parts C and D, and Medicaid managed care. 

HMA Analysis: If finalized, providers will need compliance systems to reliably identify potential overpayments, investigate the issue, quantify the amount, determine whether the problem extends to other claims, and make the appropriate report and repayment within the required timeframe. Organizations operating across Medicare, Medicaid FFS, and managed care also will need processes that account for differences in payer contracts, state Medicaid requirements, and federal rules. 

5. Home Health and Personal Care Services Face Additional EVV Scrutiny 

Federal law requires states to use Electronic Visit Verification (EVV) for specified personal care and home health services. CMS proposes to require states to incorporate EVV information into Medicaid prepayment claims review and preliminary fraud, waste, and abuse investigations. 

HMA Analysis: For home and community-based providers, this change would amplify the need for accurate and consistent EVV information. Greater reliance on EVV data in prepayment review could increase the risk of payment delays or denials when visit records do not align with claims, authorizations, or other supporting documentation. Providers may need to strengthen reconciliation processes and procedures for resolving EVV discrepancies before claims are submitted. 

Why the CMS CRUSH Rule Matters for Healthcare Providers 

CMS increasingly is seeking to connect information across enrollment, claims, ownership, provider identifiers, managed care plans, state Medicaid agencies, and federal oversight activities. 

This policy direction is particularly pertinent for organizations with large public program portfolios or complex provider networks. Increased scrutiny could have consequences beyond claims repayment, including payment suspensions, enrollment actions, operational disruption, and access to care, if providers lose their ability to participate in public programs. 

Healthcare organizations can use this period to assess which provisions have material implications for their organizations and whether CMS should consider operational, access, or implementation issues before finalizing the rule. Key questions to consider include: 

  • Is provider enrollment information accurate and current? Organizations should understand where responsibility sits for updating enrollment records after ownership, management, address, practice location, or other organizational changes. 
  • Can the organization identify and return overpayments quickly? Finance, revenue cycle, compliance, legal, and operational teams need clear escalation pathways when a potential Medicaid or Medicare overpayment is identified. 
  • Do documentation and billing records align? For services subject to heightened scrutiny, including home health, personal care, DMEPOS, laboratory, and behavioral health services, organizations should be able to connect the billed service with medical necessity, authorization, provider credentials, and service documentation. 
  • Could an issue in one program create broader exposure? As CMS strengthens information sharing and aligns enrollment authorities across Medicare and Medicaid, organizations operating across programs should assess risk on an enterprise basis. 
  • Are compliance and program integrity functions positioned to prevent problems, not simply respond to audits? Earlier screening, prepayment review, analytics, and coordinated enforcement increase the value of identifying vulnerabilities before they produce significant repayment or enforcement exposure. 

More broadly, healthcare executives should view CRUSH alongside CMS’s other 2026 program integrity actions. The agency has expanded its focus on provider enrollment, strengthened scrutiny of high-risk provider types, increased Medicaid analytics and federal-state coordination, and emphasized preventing questionable payments before they occur. CMS’s decision to pursue recurring program integrity rulemaking suggests these issues will remain prominent in 2027. 

How HMA Can Help Healthcare Organizations Prepare for Increased Program Integrity Oversight 

Health Management Associates (HMA) works with healthcare providers, health plans, and state Medicaid agencies to identify program integrity vulnerabilities before they become financial, compliance, or operational problems. 

For healthcare providers, HMA can assess Medicare and Medicaid enrollment processes, ownership and disclosure requirements, coding and documentation, overpayment identification and response processes, audit readiness, and high-risk service lines. Our teams combine Medicaid and Medicare policy expertise with clinical, operational, payment integrity, compliance, and data analytics experience to translate federal requirements into practical changes organizations can implement. 

Connect with HMA to assess your program integrity readiness, identify the provisions most relevant to your organization, and prioritize actions that can strengthen compliance and reduce financial and operational risk as CMS’s oversight strategy evolves. 

Ready to talk?