Blog
View all blogs

Medicaid Community Engagement Requirements: CMS Offers States Six-Month Hold Harmless Period

Implications for States, Health Plans, and Providers 

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) has announced new flexibility for states implementing Medicaid community engagement requirements under P.L. 119-21, commonly known as the One Big Beautiful Bill Act and referred to by CMS as the Working Families Tax Cut (WFTC) legislation. In a November 13, 2026, State Medicaid Director letter (SMD #26-006), CMS established an optional six-month “hold harmless” transition period during which states may suspend eligibility denials and disenrollments when otherwise eligible individuals fail to demonstrate that they satisfy community engagement requirements or qualify for an exclusion or exception. 

The guidance follows an October 29, 2026, federal court decision that struck down part of CMS’s approach to determining who qualifies for the medical frailty exclusion. 

As a result, states may temporarily suspend eligibility denials and disenrollments for community engagement noncompliance through June 30, 2027, but must continue to prepare for full implementation. So while this flexibility is meaningful for states with unfinished systems work, new verification processes, data limitations, and the prospect of significant beneficiary confusion, it is not a six-month delay of the January 1, 2027, effective date.

In this article, Health Management Associates (HMA) addresses the implications the guidance carries for Medicaid managed care organizations (MCOs), healthcare providers, and other organizations seeking to minimize coverage disruptions and maintain access to care. 

Medicaid Hold Harmless Period: What CMS’s Optional Six-Month Transition Allows 

The WFTC Act mandates that adults ages 19–64 enrolled in the Medicaid expansion group or certain Section 1115 demonstrations meet community engagement requirements unless they qualify for an exclusion or exception. Individuals can satisfy the requisites by completing 80 hours per month of employment or community service, enrolling at least half-time in an educational program, participating in other qualifying activities, or earning a monthly income equivalent to at least 80 hours of work at the federal minimum wage. Individuals who are pregnant, caregivers, medically frail, or included in other specified populations, are excluded from the requirements. 

CMS’s November guidance allows states to request a transition period from the implementation date of January 1, 2027, through June 30, 2027. During an approved period, a state could process an application or renewal and determine that an individual did not meet the community engagement requirements but nevertheless can retain their Medicaid coverage.

Notably, states have the option of not using the full six months or opting out entirely. States considering a January 1, 2027, start to the hold harmless period, however, must notify CMS by December 11, 2026. States also need CMS approval of their mitigation plans. 

States are making this decision while facing another important change in the implementation landscape. In last week’s article, HMA addressed a federal district court’s decision in Massachusetts v. Oz to strike a provision of CMS’s interim final rule requiring people with qualifying medical conditions to demonstrate that their condition significantly impairs their ability to comply with community engagement requirements. 

The court separately granted the plaintiff jurisdictions a six-month stay of federal enforcement related to determinations of whether individuals qualify as medically frail. That plaintiff-specific relief is distinct from CMS’s SMD guidance, which makes an optional hold harmless period available to all states with populations subject to the community engagement requirement. CMS acknowledges the court ruling and clarifies that states are not expected to implement the invalidated medical frailty provision.

Also of note, CMS advises states that eligibility determinations made consistent with an approved mitigation plan will not be treated as inaccuracies under the Payment Error Rate Measurement (PERM), Medicaid Eligibility Quality Control (MEQC), or other CMS Medicaid beneficiary eligibility audits. This regulatory approach provides states more latitude to work through implementation problems without simultaneously increasing federal eligibility audit exposure. 

Decisions about hold harmless will differ by state. Medicaid organizations operating in multiple states will need state-specific strategies to track these decisions and the implementation environment. 

State Medicaid Agency Implementation Activities During the Hold Harmless Period 

CMS’s announcement may have the immediate effect of fewer coverage losses in states that select the hold harmless option, but state Medicaid agencies will still need to work through substantial implementation initiatives, including: 

  • Developing eligibility systems capable of checking exclusions before assessing community engagement activities 
  • Establishing usable data connections for verifying employment, income, education, and other qualifying activities 
  • Confirming medical frailty policies and system rules need reflect the court decision 
  • Explaining increasingly complicated eligibility rules in ways Medicaid enrollees can use 
  • Preparing appeals and customer service operations for cases that do not fit neatly into automated processes 

State Medicaid agencies that elect the hold harmless period and provide a specific timeline to full implementation will have an opportunity to test eligibility systems, improve automated verification, strengthen member communications, and identify administrative barriers before they result in coverage losses. States must also ensure that their medical frailty policies and verification procedures reflect the court’s ruling. These considerations are particularly relevant for states that have yet to complete necessary system modifications or data-sharing arrangements. 

Implications of the CMS Hold Harmless Period for Health Plans and Providers 

The combined effect of CMS’s guidance and the court ruling creates both opportunities and challenges for states and their Medicaid partners as they prepare for implementation. CMS’s November guidance may have the immediate effect of fewer coverage losses in states that elect the hold harmless option. 

Medicaid MCOs. The hold harmless period may reduce the number of near-term disenrollments that Medicaid health plans were projecting, although the timing and extent of those effects will vary by state. Plans should be looking closely at which states use the hold harmless option, when each state expects to begin full enforcement, how MCO members will be identified and notified, and where plan data or member engagement capabilities could resolve eligibility issues. Plans also should prepare for possible enrollment volatility when the transition period expires. 

Healthcare Providers. For providers, particularly hospitals, community health centers, and other safety-net organizations, the hold harmless period may help preserve continuity of coverage and care in the near term. The court’s elimination of the additional functional impairment test could also simplify medical frailty determinations by removing the need to document how a qualifying condition affects an individual’s ability to meet community engagement requirements. Providers may nevertheless become a front door for questions when patients receive notices, cannot document compliance, or believe they qualify for an exclusion. Hospitals, health centers, behavioral health organizations, and other safety-net providers also should be considering how eligibility changes could affect uncompensated care, revenue cycle operations, patient navigation, and continuity of treatment. 

Looking Ahead: Preparing for Medicaid Community Engagement Requirements 

The coming months will be critical for states and their Medicaid partners as they work to implement community engagement requirements while minimizing unnecessary coverage disruptions. The effectiveness of the hold harmless period will depend on how states use the additional time to strengthen eligibility verification, data sharing, and beneficiary communications before full enforcement begins. 

Senior leaders in Medicaid organizations should therefore be asking a series of specific questions, including: 

  • What is our state planning to do? 
  • When will adverse actions begin? 
  • Which populations are most likely to be affected? 
  • What will happen to enrollment when the transition ends? 
  • And where could weaknesses in data, systems, communications, or consumer support create avoidable coverage loss? 

Those questions are critical to organizations’ planning and operations as January 1, 2027, approaches. 

How HMA Can Help 

HMA is helping state Medicaid agencies, health plans, providers, and other stakeholders navigate evolving community engagement requirements and prepare for implementation. Our policy, operational, actuarial, and analytics experts can assist organizations with the following: 

  • Implementation Readiness and Planning. Assess operational readiness, evaluate the implications of the optional hold harmless period, and identify priorities for systems, eligibility processes, and implementation planning 
  • Enrollment and Financial Impact Analysis. Model potential changes in Medicaid enrollment, coverage disruptions, and financial implications for states, health plans, and providers under different implementation scenarios 
  • Eligibility Verification and Coverage Safeguards. Review verification processes, medical frailty exclusions, and operational safeguards to help minimize unnecessary coverage losses 
  • Stakeholder Communications and Outreach. Develop targeted communications and outreach strategies to help beneficiaries understand requirements, exclusions, and available assistance 

Contact HMA’s Medicaid experts to discuss how your organization can prepare for these federal and state developments. 

Ready to talk?